Justice Wasiu Animahun of a Lagos High Court in Igbosere has dismissed a
N50 million suit filed by a telecommunication company, Globacom Limited,
against the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC) for threatening to
arrest and
detain its Head of Marketing Department, Mr. Ashok Israni, over a
petition by a foreign firm.
A Dubai-based firm, Emitac Mobile Solutions, LLNP, had in the petition
accused Globacom of refusing to pay the sum of $6, 685, 312. 88 being the
balance of the service it rendered to the telecommunication outfit.
However, in his arguments, Globacom’s lawyer, O. Uye, disclosed that
there was nothing criminal in the transaction for the EFCC to investigate.
According to him, disagreement over the alleged debt arose owing to a
dispute between his client and the foreign firm with respect to service
delivery.
In his own submissions, EFCC’s lawyer, G. J. Ochia, said the commission
had to wade into the matter because there was a reasonable suspicion that a
crime has been committed.
The lawyer while urging the judge to dismiss the suit said no competent
affidavit has been placed before the court.
According to him, it is improper for a legal officer at Globacom’s office
to depose to the affidavit in support of the suit because it amounts to an
infringement on the provisions of Order 2 Rule 4 of the Fundamental Rights
Enforcement Procedure Rules.
He maintained that the proper person to depose to the affidavit is the
Head of Marketing Department, Mr. Ashok Israni, whose rights were allegedly
violated.
Lawyer to the foreign firm, George Chiekwe, also urged the court not to
entertain the suit because his client has been unduly defrauded by Globacom.
In his judgement, Justice Animahun agreed with the anti-graft agency that
there was a reasonable suspicion that an offence of obtaining by false pretence
has been committed and as such the commission is in order to wade into the
matter.
The court subsequently dismissed the plaintiffs’ motion on notice and
awarded N150, 000 to each of the respondents.
“There is a reasonable suspicion that an offence of obtaining by false
pretence has been committed. A reasonable suspicion that an offence has been
committed is a justification to infringe the right guaranteed under Chapter IV
of the Constitution.
“Consequently, I hold that originating motion on notice dated July 19,
fails and is hereby dismissed with N150, 000 costs in favour of each set of the
respondents”, the judge held.
In a 28-paragraph affidavit in support of the suit deposed to by one,
Olumide Taye Babafemi , a legal officer at Globacom Limited, it was averred that the issues between the
telecommunication outfit and the foreign firm are purely contractual arising
from a framework agreement which clearly provided for modalities to address any
disagreement.
However, the foreign firm in its counter-affidavit averred that the
failure of Globacom Limited to pay the sum of $6, 685, 312. 88, being the
balance of the service rendered to it for the provision of Blackbery
Solutions (BIS), a wireless solution
that was supposed to allow Glo mobile users access communications and
information wirelessly, has resulted in the winding up of its operations in
Nigeria and this had led to the laying off of about 95 percent of its staff.
The foreign firm also averred that Globacom Limited made it to render
service under false pretence
In its counter-affidavit, the EFCC said it was only acting on a petition
written against the telecommunication company over alleged fraud.
The anti-graft agency further averred that the suit is an attempt by
Globacom Limited to forestall further investigation into the criminal aspect of
the petition and that no one is instigating it to perform its statutory
obligations.
0 Comments